Why Are You Slowing Down My WiFi, Apple? To Make Things Better?
I defend Apple a lot. When Network World wrongly accused the original iPhone of flooding Duke University's network, I defended Apple. (It was later found to be a Cisco problem.) When a health care provider I was doing some work for blamed SIP-enabled iPhones for a VoIP problem, I eventually found out that the APs were to blame. (The APs were failing to respond to WiFi frames tagged as "Background" QoS.) Time and time again networking folks blame device makers like Apple, and time and time again the problem ends up being the network.
There are times, however, when it really is Apple's fault. When the network is operating just fine. This is one of those times. The problem is that I just don't know why.
802.11n (HT) and 802.11ac (VHT) networks operate in co-existence with first generation (802.11a/b/g, that is) WiFi a lot. When that happens, the HT or VHT access point operates in mixed mode.
There are all sorts of ramifications when a WiFi network operates in mixed mode, but one of the bigger ones (a ramification that usually results in a throughput loss between 25% and 40%) is the protection mechanism. When the the AP operates in mixed mode, it transmits data using the protection mechanism and it uses Beacon and Probe Response frames to tell WiFi devices to use the protection mechanism. An AP or device using the protection mechanism will precede its data frame transmissions with the transmission of a non-data carrying frame called a request to send (RTS) or a clear to send (CTS). The RTS and CTS frames are always sent at a data rate that the legacy devices can understand. For example, a WiFi network with a mix of 802.11a and 802.11ac devices would see 802.11a (24 Mbps, typically) RTS and/or CTS frames sent in advance of data that would be sent using VHT rates (up to 1,300 Mbps with today's gear).
An important note in all of this is that if there is no mixed mode, then there doesn't need to be any protection mechanism. If you've got a bunch of HT devices all associated to an HT AP, then there shouldn't be any RTS or CTS frames slowing down the data.
Rough & Tumble Films (a movie production company whose owners I'm friends with and who have a little country noir called "We Gotta Get Out Of This Place" airing on the Starz network later this year) has a WiFi network with an HT AP and all HT (or VHT) devices. (See the Probe Request frame below showing the "R&T" network indicating that all devices are HT-capable.)
The R&T WiFi network should see HT data frames going across the WiFi channel without any RTS and/or CTS frames slowing it down. That is not, however, what shows up in my WildPackets OmniPeek capture. (See that the highlighted data frames below are sent at HT rates of 243 Mbps and 300 Mbps, but they are surrounded by RTS and CTS frames sent at 24 Mbps.)
What gives, I wondered? Are the Probe Response frames coming from the AP giving me bad information? Are devices acting up? My initial capture was done on data going to and from my laptop (MacBook Air using dual-band, two-stream 802.11n), so I wanted to add my phone to the network to see if anything was different.
When I added my phone (iPhone 5 using dual-band, single-stream 802.11n), the same behavior occurred. More 24 Mbps RTS and CTS frames were surrounding my HT (this time 135 Mbps or 150 Mbps) data.
I noticed a trend when investigating all of this protection mechanism traffic on my friends' non-mixed mode WiFi. I noticed that the RTS frames were only being sent by my devices. The APs were never sending an RTS frame. Beyond that, I noticed that when the AP was the transmitter of a data frame, neither an RTS or a CTS preceded that data frame. In short, I noticed that the AP was not using the protection mechanism, which my laptop and phone were.
I know, then, that Apple devices (both iOS and OS X) slow down the channels they are using by acting like it's mixed mode even when it's not. What I don't know is, Why? Did Apple make a mistake? Is there some HT or VHT protocol that I am unaware of that causes devices to use the protection mechanism even when APs don't? Or is Apple doing this on purpose because someone at Apple thinks that their devices function better when the protection mechanism is always on?
After seeing Apple devices voluntarily engage in the protection mechanism, it made me think back to a question that I received while doing a Reddit AMA last year. A person asked about RTS/CTS being used to manage network traffic and getting devices to cooperate. The person from Reddit mentioned that he (sorry ladies, but when his Reddit handle is "ShadowHawk109" and he posts about beer, WiFi and William Shatner, it's got to be a guy) did work in academia, so I just assumed that he didn't know what he was talking about. Maybe he was on to something. Maybe Apple believes that their devices will have a more consistent data connection over WiFi if RTS/CTS frames are being used all the time, and so they've enabled it in their devices. Maybe Apple doesn't care that much if their devices cause the maximum available throughput to be lower on the channel.
Whatever the reason may be that Apple devices have been programmed to use RTS/CTS frames, WiFi professionals are going to have to deal with the impact. It could mean that our throughput tests mean even less and that our ability to support high density deployments has been expanded.
There are times, however, when it really is Apple's fault. When the network is operating just fine. This is one of those times. The problem is that I just don't know why.
802.11n (HT) and 802.11ac (VHT) networks operate in co-existence with first generation (802.11a/b/g, that is) WiFi a lot. When that happens, the HT or VHT access point operates in mixed mode.
There are all sorts of ramifications when a WiFi network operates in mixed mode, but one of the bigger ones (a ramification that usually results in a throughput loss between 25% and 40%) is the protection mechanism. When the the AP operates in mixed mode, it transmits data using the protection mechanism and it uses Beacon and Probe Response frames to tell WiFi devices to use the protection mechanism. An AP or device using the protection mechanism will precede its data frame transmissions with the transmission of a non-data carrying frame called a request to send (RTS) or a clear to send (CTS). The RTS and CTS frames are always sent at a data rate that the legacy devices can understand. For example, a WiFi network with a mix of 802.11a and 802.11ac devices would see 802.11a (24 Mbps, typically) RTS and/or CTS frames sent in advance of data that would be sent using VHT rates (up to 1,300 Mbps with today's gear).
An important note in all of this is that if there is no mixed mode, then there doesn't need to be any protection mechanism. If you've got a bunch of HT devices all associated to an HT AP, then there shouldn't be any RTS or CTS frames slowing down the data.
Rough & Tumble Films (a movie production company whose owners I'm friends with and who have a little country noir called "We Gotta Get Out Of This Place" airing on the Starz network later this year) has a WiFi network with an HT AP and all HT (or VHT) devices. (See the Probe Request frame below showing the "R&T" network indicating that all devices are HT-capable.)
The R&T WiFi network should see HT data frames going across the WiFi channel without any RTS and/or CTS frames slowing it down. That is not, however, what shows up in my WildPackets OmniPeek capture. (See that the highlighted data frames below are sent at HT rates of 243 Mbps and 300 Mbps, but they are surrounded by RTS and CTS frames sent at 24 Mbps.)
What gives, I wondered? Are the Probe Response frames coming from the AP giving me bad information? Are devices acting up? My initial capture was done on data going to and from my laptop (MacBook Air using dual-band, two-stream 802.11n), so I wanted to add my phone to the network to see if anything was different.
When I added my phone (iPhone 5 using dual-band, single-stream 802.11n), the same behavior occurred. More 24 Mbps RTS and CTS frames were surrounding my HT (this time 135 Mbps or 150 Mbps) data.
I noticed a trend when investigating all of this protection mechanism traffic on my friends' non-mixed mode WiFi. I noticed that the RTS frames were only being sent by my devices. The APs were never sending an RTS frame. Beyond that, I noticed that when the AP was the transmitter of a data frame, neither an RTS or a CTS preceded that data frame. In short, I noticed that the AP was not using the protection mechanism, which my laptop and phone were.
I know, then, that Apple devices (both iOS and OS X) slow down the channels they are using by acting like it's mixed mode even when it's not. What I don't know is, Why? Did Apple make a mistake? Is there some HT or VHT protocol that I am unaware of that causes devices to use the protection mechanism even when APs don't? Or is Apple doing this on purpose because someone at Apple thinks that their devices function better when the protection mechanism is always on?
After seeing Apple devices voluntarily engage in the protection mechanism, it made me think back to a question that I received while doing a Reddit AMA last year. A person asked about RTS/CTS being used to manage network traffic and getting devices to cooperate. The person from Reddit mentioned that he (sorry ladies, but when his Reddit handle is "ShadowHawk109" and he posts about beer, WiFi and William Shatner, it's got to be a guy) did work in academia, so I just assumed that he didn't know what he was talking about. Maybe he was on to something. Maybe Apple believes that their devices will have a more consistent data connection over WiFi if RTS/CTS frames are being used all the time, and so they've enabled it in their devices. Maybe Apple doesn't care that much if their devices cause the maximum available throughput to be lower on the channel.
Whatever the reason may be that Apple devices have been programmed to use RTS/CTS frames, WiFi professionals are going to have to deal with the impact. It could mean that our throughput tests mean even less and that our ability to support high density deployments has been expanded.
***
If you like my blog, you can support it by shopping through my Amazon link or donating Bitcoin to 1N8m1o9phSkFXpa9VUrMVHx4LJWfratseU
Ben,
ReplyDeleteNot necessarily that RTS/CTS always slows down the overall performance.
RTS/CTS are good for reliability; especially in 11ac environment.
Infact, with 11ac, RTS-CTS protection along with AMPDU over AMSDU performs better than without RTS for all the tests that I have been doing.
Its not bad at all to do RTS-CTS anymore;
The penalty are actually very less for the extra reliability.
RTS/CTS diminishes throughput capacity. As stated in the article, if the counterweight is an improvement in consistency, then that's good.
ReplyDeleteInteresting article Ben! I have been investigating lots of RTS/CTS on my WLAN for some time and was actually hoping to garner your opinion, but couldn't find a contact-me e-mail address. I think it might be the same thing, but I'm not familiar enough with packet traces to be sure. (yet!).
ReplyDeleteben at sniffwifi dot com
ReplyDeleteI feel a lot more people need to read this, very good info
ReplyDeleteI am sure that this is going to help a lot of individuals. Keep up the good work. It is highly convincing and I enjoyed going through the entire blog.
ReplyDeletedigital marketing courses in hyderabad with placement
Great post i must say and thanks for the information. Education is definitely a sticky subject. However, is still among the leading topics of our time. I appreciate your post and look forward to more.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course in Bangalore
I want to leave a little comment to support and wish you the best of luck.we wish you the best of luck in all your blogging enedevors.
ReplyDeletedata science course in chennai
I am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site.
ReplyDeleteData Science Training in Chennai
Great post i must say and thanks for the information. Education is definitely a sticky subject. However, is still among the leading topics of our time. I appreciate your post and look forward to more.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course in Bangalore
I find your opinion quite interesting, but the other day I stumbled upon a bit of completely different advice from another blogger, I need to think that one through, thanks for posting.
ReplyDeletecertification on data analytics
Fascinating post. I Have Been considering about this issue, so thankful for posting. Totally cool post.It 's very generally very Useful post.Thanks
ReplyDeletedata science certification
This post is very simple to read and appreciate without leaving any details out. Great work!
ReplyDeletedigital marketing courses in hyderabad with placement
Thanks for sharing this information. I really like your blog post very much. You have really shared a informative and interesting blog post with people..
ReplyDeletedata scientist course
Excellent Blog! I would like to thank for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. I wanted to thank you for this websites! Thanks for sharing. Great websites!
ReplyDeleteData Science Training in Bangalore
Thanks for posting the best information and the blog is very important.artificial intelligence course in hyderabad
ReplyDeleteThanks for posting the best information and the blog is very important.data science institutes in hyderabad
ReplyDeleteI am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site.
ReplyDeleteartificial intellingence training in chennai
It's really great. Thank you for providing a quality article. There is something you might be interested in. Do you know 메이저토토 ?
ReplyDeleteI want to leave a little comment to support and wish you the best of luck.we wish you the best of luck in all your blogging enedevors.
ReplyDeletedata science training in chennai
I am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course Syllabus
It's amazing that you figured all this out on your own, and I need to learn how to do it like you.메이저토토사이트
ReplyDeletewow, great, I was wondering how to cure acne naturally. and found your site by google, learned a lot, now i’m a bit clear. I’ve bookmark your site and also add rss. keep us updated.
ReplyDeletedata scientist course in hyderabad
First of all, thank you for your post. Your posts are neatly organized with the information I want, so there are plenty of resources to reference. I bookmark this site and will find your posts frequently in the future. Thanks again ^^ 토토사이트
ReplyDeleteGood information you shared. keep posting.
ReplyDeletebest data science online course
Fantastic article I ought to say and thanks to the info. Instruction is absolutely a sticky topic. But remains one of the top issues of the time. I love your article and look forward to more.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course in Bangalore
Thank you quite much for discussing this type of helpful informative article. Will certainly stored and reevaluate your Website.
ReplyDeleteData Science certification Course in Bangalore
I finally found a great article here. I will stay here again. I just added your blog to my bookmarking sites. Thank you. Quality postings are essential to get visitors to visit the website, that's what this website offers.
ReplyDeleteBusiness Analytics Course
I'm glad I found this blog! Occasionally, students want to know the keys to writing productive literary essays. Your first-class knowledge of this great job can become a suitable foundation for these people. Good
ReplyDeleteBest Data Science Courses in Bangalore
I enjoyed the coursework, the presentations, the classmates and the teachers. And because my company reimbursed 100% of the tuition, the only cost I had to pay on my own was for books and supplies. Otherwise, I received a free master's degree. All I had to invest was my time.
ReplyDeleteData Analytics Course in Bangalore
Nice to be seeing your site once again, it's been weeks for me. This article which ive been waited for so long. I need this guide to complete my mission inside the school, and it's same issue together along with your essay. Thanks, pleasant share.
ReplyDeleteData Science training in Bangalore
I finally found a great article here. I will stay here again. I just added your blog to my bookmarking sites. Thank you. Quality postings are essential to get visitors to visit the website, that's what this website offers.
ReplyDeleteDigital Marketing Course in Bangalore
Hi Thanks for Sharing this Valuable Information with us: this is very useful for me. Keep it Up.
ReplyDeleteartificial intelligence course in aurangabad
Very wonderful informative article. I appreciated looking at your article. Very wonderful reveal. I would like to twit this on my followers. Many thanks! .
ReplyDeleteData Science certification training in Bangalore
Thanks for posting the best information and the blog is very important.digital marketing institute in hyderabad
ReplyDeletei am glad to discover this page : i have to thank you for the time i spent on this especially great reading !! i really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site.
ReplyDeleteartificial intelligence training in chennai
Are you trying to find a high DA forum submission sites list 2021?. Below is a listing of top dofollow forum entry sites in 2021 which assists you generate high quality back links and improve your traffic & position.
ReplyDeleteIt is extremely nice to see the greatest details presented in an easy and understanding manner.
ReplyDeletebusiness analytics course
I've been looking for photos and articles on this topic over the past few days due to a school assignment, and I'm really happy to find a post with the material I was looking for! I bookmark and will come often! Thanks :D 토토사이트
ReplyDeleteExcellence blog! Thanks For Sharing, The information provided by you is really a worthy. I read this blog and I got the more information about
ReplyDeletedata scientist course in pune
I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people.
ReplyDeleteBest Data Science courses in Hyderabad
This is most informative and also this post most user friendly and super navigation to all posts... Thank you so much for giving this information to me..
ReplyDeletemachine learning training in aurangabad
Thank you quite much for discussing this type of helpful informative article. Will certainly stored and reevaluate your Website.
ReplyDeleteData Analytics Course in Bangalore
Very wonderful informative article. I appreciated looking at your article. Very wonderful reveal. I would like to twit this on my followers. Many thanks! .
ReplyDeleteData Analytics training in Bangalore
GST University Admission result 2020-21 will be published by gstadmission.ac.bd website. GST Eligible List Result Published Very Soon. Candiates Guccho Admission Result check easily our website- jobnewsbd24.com
ReplyDeleteThanks for such a great post and the review, I am totally impressed! Keep stuff like this coming.
ReplyDeletedata scientist training and placement in hyderabad
Very interesting to read this article. I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article. This article inspired me to read more. keep it up.
ReplyDeleteAWS Training in Hyderabad
Hello, I read the post well. 안전놀이터추천 It's a really interesting topic and it has helped me a lot. In fact, I also run a website with similar content to your posting. Please visit once
ReplyDeleteThanks for such a fantastic blog. Where else could anyone get that kind of info written in such a perfect way? I have a presentation that I am presently writhing on, and I have been on the look out for such great information. 메이저토토
ReplyDeleteThanks for providing a useful article containing valuable information. start learning the best online software courses.
ReplyDeleteSailpoint Certification
Looker Training
F5 Load balancer Training
SAP Ariba Training
I was just examining through the web looking for certain information and ran over your blog.It shows how well you understand this subject. Bookmarked this page, will return for extra. data science course in vadodara
ReplyDeleteTremendous blog quite easy to grasp the subject since the content is very simple to understand. Obviously, this helps the participants to engage themselves in to the subject without much difficulty. Hope you further educate the readers in the same manner and keep sharing the content as always you do.
ReplyDeletedata science course in faridabad
This is the perfect post.안전놀이터 It helped me a lot. If you have time, I hope you come to my site and share your opinions. Have a nice day.
ReplyDeleteReally nice and interesting post. I was looking for this kind of information and enjoyed reading this one. Keep posting. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeletedata scientist course in malaysia
Truly overall quite fascinating post. I was searching for this sort of data and delighted in perusing this one. Continue posting. Much obliged for sharing.artificial intelligence course in chennai
ReplyDeleteI am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course in Hyderabad
Hi. I have just found a very good site which talks about VIN decoder, visit their website here. You can use the tool to inquire information on any car's history by finding the detail on its VIN number. Let me know how your experience with it after using the tool.
ReplyDeleteI want to leave a little comment to support and wish you the best of luck.we wish you the best of luck in all your blogging enedevors.
ReplyDeleteaws training in hyderabad
First of all, thank you for your post. Bóng88 Your posts are neatly organized with the information I want, so there are plenty of resources to reference. I bookmark this site and will find your posts frequently in the future. Thanks again ^^
ReplyDeleteHighly appreciable regarding the uniqueness of the content. This perhaps makes the readers feels excited to get stick to the subject. Certainly, the learners would thank the blogger to come up with the innovative content which keeps the readers to be up to date to stand by the competition. Once again nice blog keep it up and keep sharing the content as always.
ReplyDeletedata science course in faridabad
I was looking for another article by chance and found your articlesex I am writing on this topic, so I think it will help a lot. I leave my blog address below. Please visit once.
ReplyDeleteYou can now easily login for a favorite online casino
ReplyDeleteand click on the mobile tab. Not everybody is able to find
a very good site as a way to make use of the cheap deals and entertainment though.
Nowadays gaming websites provides best features and functionalities
that assure an interactive platform.오피사이트
Fabulous post, you have denoted out some fantastic points, I likewise think this s a very wonderful website. I will visit again for more quality contents and also, recommend this site to all. Thanks. 토토사이트추천
ReplyDeleteAppreciate the effort and information you have given in writing this article .카지노사이트
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing this information. I read your blog and I can't stop my self to read your full blog. Again Thanks and Best of luck to your next Blog in future.바카라사이트
ReplyDeleteIts an amazing website, I really enjoy reading your articles. 토토사이트
ReplyDeleteI finally found great post here. Thanks for the information. Please keep sharing more articles.카지노사이트
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, thank you for your post. Your posts are neatly organized with the information I want, so there are plenty of resources to reference. I bookmark this site and will find your posts frequently in the future. Thanks again ^^ Keo hay
ReplyDeleteI am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course Syllabus
Extremely overall quite fascinating post. I was searching for this sort of data and delighted in perusing this one. Continue posting. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing. data scientist course in delhi
ReplyDeleteThanks for your marvelous posting! I actually enjoyed reading it, you could be
ReplyDeletea great author.I will remember to bookmark your blog and will
eventually come back from now on. I want to encourage you to continue your great
writing, have a nice weekend!
Website:온라인바카라
Stupendous blog huge applause to the blogger and hoping you to come up with such an extraordinary content in future. Surely, this post will inspire many aspirants who are very keen in gaining the knowledge. Expecting many more contents with lot more curiosity further.
ReplyDeleteData Science Certification in Bhilai
Extraordinary blog went amazed with the content that they have developed in a very descriptive manner. This type of content surely ensures the participants to explore themselves. Hope you deliver the same near the future as well. Gratitude to the blogger for the efforts.
ReplyDeleteData Science Training
I want to leave a little comment to support and wish you the best of luck.we wish you the best of luck in all your blogging enedevors.
ReplyDeletebusiness analytics courses
Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you. 먹튀검증 and I am very happy to see your post just in time and it was a great help. Thank you ! Leave your blog address below. Please visit me anytime!
ReplyDeleteIt's good to visit your blog again, it's been months for me. Well, this article that I have been waiting for so long. I will need this post to complete my college homework, and it has the exact same topic with your article. Thanks, have a good game.
ReplyDeleteBusiness Analytics Course
If you are looking for Illinois license plate sticker renewals online, you have to go to the right place. We have the fastest Illinois license plate sticker renewals in the state.
ReplyDeleteBest Data Science Courses in Bangalore
As I am looking at your writing, I regret being unable to do outdoor activities due to Corona 19, and I miss my old daily life. If you also miss the daily life of those days, would you please visit my site once? My site is a site where I post about photos and daily life when I was free.bong88
ReplyDeleteThey are produced by high level developers who will stand out for the creation of their polo dress. You will find Ron Lauren polo shirts in an exclusive range which includes private lessons for men and women.
ReplyDeleteData Analytics Course in Bangalore
I recently came across your article and read it. I want to express my admiration for your writing skills and your ability to get readers to read from start to finish. I would love to read more recent articles and share my thoughts with you.
ReplyDeleteDigital Marketing Course in Bangalore
Informative blog
ReplyDeletedata analytics courses in hyderabad
I blog often and I truly appreciate your content.
ReplyDelete야설
Feel free to visit my blog :
야설
This great article has truly peaked my interest.
ReplyDelete일본야동
Feel free to visit my blog : 일본야동
I’m going to bookmark your site and keep checking for new details about once per week.
ReplyDelete국산야동
Feel free to visit my blog : 국산야동
I subscribed to your Feed too.
ReplyDelete일본야동
Feel free to visit my blog : 일본야동
Really impressed! Everything is very open and very clear clarification of issues. It contains true facts. Your website is very valuable. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeletereal estate company
You published a wonderful short article. I was extremely touched after I saw your writing, and also I actually suched as the tale of what I was seeking due to the fact that it consisted of every little thing. I'm so interested concerning just how you thought about this details and also exactly how you discovered it. Take a look at my writing as well as let me understand. 바카라사이트
ReplyDeleteI am impressed by the information that you have on this blog. It shows how well you understand this subject.
ReplyDeletedata scientist training in malaysia
Someone necessarily help to make significantly articles I would state.
ReplyDeleteThis is the first time I frequented your website page and thus far?
click me here카지노
yang
You completely match our expectation and the variety of our information.
ReplyDeletedata scientist course
Thank you for sharing wonderful content
ReplyDeletedata scientist training in aurangabad
Thanks for posting the best information and the blog is very good.data science course in Lucknow
ReplyDeleteYou completely match our expectation and the variety of our information.
ReplyDeletedata science course in malaysia
That's a really impressive new idea! 메이저토토사이트추천 It touched me a lot. I would love to hear your opinion on my site. Please come to the site I run once and leave a comment. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteIt is extremely nice to see the greatest details presented in an easy and understanding manner.
ReplyDeletedata scientist course
You have completed certain reliable points there. I did some research on the subject and found that almost everyone will agree with your blog.
ReplyDeleteDigital Marketing Course in Bangalore
Very good message. I came across your blog and wanted to tell you that I really enjoyed reading your articles.
ReplyDeleteBusiness Analytics Course
Very good message. I came across your blog and wanted to tell you that I really enjoyed reading your articles.
ReplyDeleteBest Data Science Courses in Bangalore
ReplyDeleteVery good message. I came across your blog and wanted to tell you that I really enjoyed reading your articles.
Data Analytics Course in Bangalore
When I read your article on this topic, the first thought seems profound and difficult. There is also a bulletin board for discussion of articles and photos similar to this topic on my site, but I would like to visit once when I have time to discuss this topic. 안전토토사이트
ReplyDeleteYour internet site has excellent material. I believe it was a great chance to alter my mind once more after reading this post. I'm composing like you. Would certainly you such as to see my blog post and also request for responses? 바카라사이트
ReplyDeleteExcellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch as I found it for him smile Therefore let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch. 메이저사이트
ReplyDeleteWe are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work
ReplyDeletedata science training in malaysia
I am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course in Delhi
Many thanks for the article, I have a lot of spray lining knowledge but always learn something new. Keep up the good work and thank you again. 메이저사이트모음
ReplyDeleteI accidentally searched and visited your site. I still saw several posts during my visit, but the text was neat and readable. I will quote this post and post it on my blog. Would you like to visit my blog later? Feel free to visit my website; 바카라사이트
ReplyDeleteWonderful items from you, man. I’ve have in mind your stuff previous to and you’re just extremely excellent. I actually like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you’re saying and the way in which through which you assert it. You’re making it entertaining and you still care for to keep it smart. I cant wait to read far more from you. That is actually a terrific web site. Feel free to visit my website; 바카라사이트
ReplyDeleteHello there, You have performed an excellent job. I will definitely dig it and personally suggest to my friends. I’m confident they will be benefited from this web site. Feel free to visit my website; 바카라사이트
ReplyDeleteHard to ignore such an amazing article like this. You really amazed me with your writing talent. Thank for you shared again. Feel free to visit my website; 바카라
ReplyDeleteI accidentally searched and visited your site. I still saw several posts during my visit, but the text was neat and readable. I will quote this post and post it on my blog. Would you like to visit my blog later? 토토사이트순위
ReplyDeleteThis is the perfect post.메이저토토사이트 It helped me a lot. If you have time, I hope you come to my site and share your opinions. Have a nice day.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the informative and helpful post, obviously in your blog everything is good..
ReplyDeletedata science course in malaysia
"Thank you very much for your information.
ReplyDeleteFrom,
"
ai training in chennai
I feel very grateful that I read this. It is very helpful and very informative and I really learned a lot from it.
ReplyDeletedata science training
I am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course in Gurgaon
A commitment of gratefulness is all together for such a phenomenal post and the audit, I am completely pushed! Keep stuff like this coming. ufa168
ReplyDeleteThanks for the blog filled with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for. Now my task has become as easy as ABC. 안전놀이터
ReplyDeleteSucceed! It could be one of the most useful blogs we have ever come across on the subject. Excellent info! I’m also an expert in this topic so I can understand your effort very well. Thanks for the huge help. 안전놀이터
ReplyDeleteI was just examining through the web looking for certain information and ran over your blog.It shows how well you understand this subject. Bookmarked this page, will return for extra. data science course in vadodara
ReplyDeleteI always think about what is. It seems to be a perfect article that seems to blow away such worries. 먹튀검증사이트 seems to be the best way to show something. When you have time, please write an article about what means!!
ReplyDeletePapers get to operate through Bible helpers and also plagiarism checkers to be certain that the author did not find idle at any stage in the process. Language inconsistencies won't be a thing with your newspapers as the specialists of our school paper writing support are passionate about writing and are always excited to strike you with something fresh. By: 안전놀이터
ReplyDeleteI figure this article can be enhanced a tad. There are a couple of things that are dangerous here, and if you somehow managed to change these things, this article could wind up a standout amongst your best ones. I have a few thoughts with respect to how you can change these things. 메이저놀이터
ReplyDeletehe blog was how do i say it… relevant, finally something that helped me. Thanks온라인경마
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing this article. This article was very helpful to me. Keep moving. 파워볼
ReplyDeleteVery informative blog, This blog is very easy to understand when compared to other blogs. 경마사이트
ReplyDeleteYour article looks really adorable, here's a site link i dropped for you which you may like.
ReplyDelete릴게임
I really like it when people come together and share ideas.
ReplyDeleteGreat website, keep it up! 스포츠토토
This could be the proper weblog for everyone who is really wants to be made aware of this topic 야동 . You recognize a great deal of its nearly difficult to argue together with you (not that I just would want…Ha Ha). You definitely put a new spin using a topic that been revealed for years. Fantastic stuff, just wonderful!
ReplyDeleteThis site is known as a walk-by way of for the entire data you wished about this and didn’t know who to ask 립카페. Glimpse right here, and you’ll positively discover it.
ReplyDeleteI’d have to talk to you here 마사지블루. Which isn’t something Which I do! I love to reading a post that should get people to think. Also, thank you for allowing me to comment!
ReplyDeleteI just want to say I’m new to blogs and certainly savored this blog site. Very likely I’m planning to bookmark your blog 출장마사지. You amazingly have fantastic articles. Thanks for sharing your blog.
ReplyDeleteNature has always developed into handy somehow or maybe the other. There are various herbs and plants which have been extracted to be played with for a lot of reasons
ReplyDelete국내경마
magosucowep
Thank you for this wonderful post! It has long been extremely helpful. 메이저사이트I wish that you will carry on posting your knowledge with us.
ReplyDeleteFairly certain he will have a good read. Thank you for sharing! 카지노
ReplyDeleteThis is very interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. 온라인카지노
ReplyDeleteHi there, after reading this remarkable paragraph i am too happy to share my experience here with friends. 바카라사이트
ReplyDeleteIt has a good meaning. If you always live positively, someday good things will happen. 메이저사이트Let's believe in the power of positivity. Have a nice day.
ReplyDeleteExtremely overall quite fascinating post. I was searching for this sort of data and delighted in perusing this one. Continue posting. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing.cloud computing course fee in hyderabad
ReplyDeleteExtraordinary post I should state and a debt of gratitude is in order for the data. Instruction is unquestionably a clingy subject. Be that as it may, is still among the main subjects within recent memory. I value your post and anticipate more.data science training in lucknow
ReplyDeleteIt is my first visit to your blog, and I am very impressed with the articles that you serve. Give adequate knowledge for me. Thank you for sharing useful material. I will be back for the more great post. 먹튀검증사이트 But by chance looking at your post solved my problem! I will leave my blog, so when would you like to visit it?!
ReplyDeleteHi there, I enjoy reading all of your article. 파워볼 하는법
ReplyDeletegreat post really appreciable work. That will be valuable to everyone who uses it, including myself. Many thanks... 경마
ReplyDeleteTwo full thumbs up for this magneficent article of yours. I've really enjoyed reading this article today and I think this might be one of the best article that I've read yet. Please, keep this work going on in the same quality. artificial intelligence training in delhi
ReplyDeleteis one very interesting post. 메이저사이트I like the way you write and I will bookmark your blog to my favorites.
ReplyDeleteMuch obliged for giving a helpful article containing significant Information.
ReplyDeleteAI Training in Hyderabad
I think this article is very good to be read by everyone, especially for readers who create inspiration to create a best blog. Hopefully in the future can provide the best inspiration for everyone .. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteBest Refrigerator Repair Service in Hyderabad
Amazingly by and large very interesting post. I was looking for such information and thoroughly enjoyed examining this one. Keep posting. An obligation of appreciation is all together for sharing.
ReplyDeleteethical hacking in hyderabad
Really nice and interesting post. I was looking for this kind of information and enjoyed reading this one. Keep posting. Thanks for sharing
ReplyDeletedata analytics courses in hyderabad
Awesome article! I want people to know just how good this information is in your article. It’s interesting, compelling content. Your views are much like my own concerning this subject 먹튀검증 It touched me a lot. I would love to hear your opinion on my site. Please come to the site I run once and leave a comment. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteYour article is great. I think it will be praised anywhere provide on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work. 안전토토
ReplyDeleteI like your blog. i ma happy to read your blog its very informative and your blog is really good and impressive you made it mice 안전토토
ReplyDeleteIt s really amazing here. I want to say that your amazing. I learn and learn a lot of useful information. 토토커뮤니티
ReplyDeleteThis kind of clever work and reporting! Keep up the very good works guys I ve added you guys to our blogroll. 안전토토
ReplyDeleteI didn t know there was a place like this. I think it s good because there are many good comments. Let s get along well from now on. 먹튀검증사이트
ReplyDeleteThis is my first time i visit here and I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially it's discussion, thank you. artificial intelligence training in delhi
ReplyDeleteRecently, I have started to read a lot of unique articles on different sites, and I am enjoying that a lot. Although, I must tell you that I still like the articles here a lot. They are also unique in their own way. 메이저놀이터
ReplyDeleteI recently came across your article and have been reading along. I want to express my admiration of your writing skill and ability to make readers read from the beginning to the end.
ReplyDeleteData Analytics Courses In Pune
I accidentally searched and visited your site. I still saw several posts during my visit, but the text was neat and readable. I will quote this post and post it on my blog. Would you like to visit my blog later? keonha cai
ReplyDeleteAmazing article..!! Thank you so much for this informative post. I found some interesting points and lots of information from your blog. Thanks 메이저놀이터
ReplyDeleteWhat a post I've been looking for! I'm very happy to finally read this post. 안전놀이터 Thank you very much. Can I refer to your post on my website? Your post touched me a lot and helped me a lot. If you have any questions, please visit my site and read what kind of posts I am posting. I am sure it will be interesting.
ReplyDeleteIt's too bad to check your article late. I wonder what it would be if we met a little faster. I want to exchange a little more, but please visit my site 온라인카지노 and leave a message!!
ReplyDeleteSuperbly written article, if only all bloggers offered the same content as you, the internet would be a far better place..
ReplyDeletecloud computing in hyderabad
Impressive blog to be honest definitely this post will inspire many more upcoming aspirants. Eventually, this makes the participants to experience and innovate themselves through knowledge wise by visiting this kind of a blog. Once again excellent job keep inspiring with your cool stuff.
ReplyDeleteData Science Training in Bhilai
Wonderful blog found to be very impressive to come across such an awesome blog. I should really appreciate the blogger for the efforts they have put in to develop such an amazing content for all the curious readers who are very keen of being updated across every corner. Ultimately, this is an awesome experience for the readers. Anyways, thanks a lot and keep sharing the content in future too.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course in Bhilai
Extremely decent blog and articles. I am realy extremely glad to visit your blog. Presently I am discovered which I really need. I check your blog regular and attempt to take in something from your blog. Much obliged to you and sitting tight for your new post.메이저사이트모음
ReplyDeleteYour work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts
ReplyDeletedata scientist course in malaysia
Hello! Nice to meet you, I say . The name of the community I run is 메리트카지노, and the community I run contains articles similar to your blog. If you have time, I would be very grateful if you visit my site .
ReplyDeleteWhat a nice post! I'm so happy to read this. 안전놀이터모음 What you wrote was very helpful to me. Thank you. Actually, I run a site similar to you. If you have time, could you visit my site? Please leave your comments after reading what I wrote. If you do so, I will actively reflect your opinion. I think it will be a great help to run my site. Have a good day.
ReplyDeleteHello, I read the post well. casino online It's a really interesting topic and it has helped me a lot. In fact, I also run a website with similar content to your posting. Please visit once
ReplyDeleteYour article has answered the question I was wondering about! I would like to write a thesis on this subject, but I would like you to give your opinion once :Dsòng bạc
ReplyDeleteHello, I am one of the most impressed people in your article. 슬롯사이트 If possible, please visit my website as well. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteYour writing is perfect and complete. 크레이지슬롯 However, I think it will be more wonderful if your post includes additional topics that I am thinking of. I have a lot of posts on my site similar to your topic. Would you like to visit once?
ReplyDeleteAre you the one who studies this subject?? I have a headache with this subject.우리카지노Looking at your writing was very helpful.
ReplyDeleteTraditional bookstores have always existed on high streets, but in the digital age, the internet is proving to become a serious competitor to traditional brick and mortar stores. This article examines both sides of the coin and provides an appropriate insight into the phenomenon of shopping of books online. 메이저사이트추천
ReplyDeletePlease keep on posting such quality articles as this is a rare thing to find these days. I am always searching online for posts that can help me. watching forward to another great blog. Good luck to the author! all the best! 스포츠토토사이트
ReplyDeleteI am a 슬롯사이트 expert. I've read a lot of articles, but I'm the first person to understand as well as you. I leave a post for the first time. It's great!!
ReplyDeleteHi there, I simply hopped over in your website by way of StumbleUpon. Now not one thing I’d typically learn, but I favored your emotions none the less. Thank you for making something worth reading. 메이저사이트순위
ReplyDeleteYoure so right. Im there with you. Your weblog is definitely worth a read if anyone comes throughout it. Im lucky I did because now Ive received a whole new view of this. 메이저사이트추천
ReplyDeleteI have been looking for articles on these topics for a long time. 카지노사이트 I don't know how grateful you are for posting on this topic. Thank you for the numerous articles on this site, I will subscribe to those links in my bookmarks and visit them often. Have a nice day
ReplyDeleteYour ideas inspired me very much. 메이저토토사이트모음 It's amazing. I want to learn your writing skills. In fact, I also have a website. If you are okay, please visit once and leave your opinion. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteMany thanks for the article, I have a lot of spray lining knowledge but always learn something new. Keep up the good work and thank you again. 메이저사이트모음
ReplyDeleteImpressive. Your story always bring hope and new energy. Keep up the good work. Data Scientist Course in Vadodara
ReplyDeleteYou made some good points there. I did a Google search about the topic and found most people will believe your blog. 메이저사이트
ReplyDeleteHello, I read the post well. 메이저토토 It's a really interesting topic and it has helped me a lot. In fact, I also run a website with similar content to your posting. Please visit once
ReplyDeleteYour post is very interesting to me. Reading was so much fun. I think the reason reading is fun is because it is a post related to that I am interested in. Articles related to 온카지노 you are the best. I would like you to write a similar post about !
ReplyDeleteGood Post.
ReplyDeleteBest University for Legal Studies in Uttarakhand
안전메이저놀이터 BET SELECTION SECRETS
ReplyDeleteI was impressed by your writing. Your writing is impressive. I want to write like you.안전놀이터 I hope you can read my post and let me know what to modify. My writing is in I would like you to visit my blog.
ReplyDeleteExcellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch as I found it for him smile Therefore let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch. 메이저사이트
ReplyDeleteThat's a really impressive new idea! 메이저토토사이트추천 It touched me a lot. I would love to hear your opinion on my site. Please come to the site I run once and leave a comment. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteUFC President Dana White Playing 바둑이게임 on Ultimate Casino
ReplyDeleteThanks for your marvelous posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you could be a great author. I will be sure to bookmark your blog and definitely will come back in the foreseeable future. I want to encourage you to continue your great posts, have a nice afternoon! Digital Marketing Course in Bangalore with Placement
ReplyDeleteJio Sim Home Delivery- see how to order jio sim from home.
ReplyDeleteMetaverse kya hai- know what is metaverse.
Web 3.0 kya hai- Know what is web 3.0 and how powerful it is.
Blockchain kya hai-Know What Is blockchain
RDP Server kya Hai
NFT in Hindi-An NFT, which stands for a non-fungible token, is a unique unit of data employing technology that allows digital content.
ReplyDeleteNft Kya HaiAn NFT, which stands for a non-fungible token, is a unique unit of data employing technology that allows digital content.
ReplyDeleteYou made some good points there. I did a Google search about the topic and found most people will believe your blog. kèo nhà cái
ReplyDeleteThat is the reason consentrate on you will need to unique placement of feet some time before authoring. Will likely be doable to help far more suitable writing in this fashion 안전놀이터
ReplyDeleteNice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites. I stumbleupon on a daily basis. It will always be exciting to read articles from other writers and use something from their Websites. แทงบอลไม่มีขั้นต่ำ
ReplyDeleteNice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here . I’m going to read this. I’ll be sure to come back. thanks for sharing. and also This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. this is very nice one and gives indepth information. thanks for this nice article. I was surfing the Internet for information and came across your blog. I am impressed by the information you have on this blog. It shows how well you understand this subject. 승인전화없는토토사이트
ReplyDeleteThanks for every other informative site. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such an ideal means? I have a venture that I’m just now operating on, and I have been on the look out for such information. Subsequently, after spending many hours on the internet at last We've uncovered an individual that definitely does know what they are discussing many thanks a great deal wonderful post. I like review goals which understand the cost of passing on the marvelous strong asset futile out of pocket. I truly revered investigating your posting. Appreciative to you! 먹튀검증
ReplyDelete