Why Are You Slowing Down My WiFi, Apple? To Make Things Better?

I defend Apple a lot.  When Network World wrongly accused the original iPhone of flooding Duke University's network, I defended Apple.  (It was later found to be a Cisco problem.)  When a health care provider I was doing some work for blamed SIP-enabled iPhones for a VoIP problem, I eventually found out that the APs were to blame.  (The APs were failing to respond to WiFi frames tagged as "Background" QoS.)  Time and time again networking folks blame device makers like Apple, and time and time again the problem ends up being the network.

There are times, however, when it really is Apple's fault.  When the network is operating just fine.  This is one of those times.  The problem is that I just don't know why.

802.11n (HT) and 802.11ac (VHT) networks operate in co-existence with first generation (802.11a/b/g, that is) WiFi a lot.  When that happens, the HT or VHT access point operates in mixed mode.

There are all sorts of ramifications when a WiFi network operates in mixed mode, but one of the bigger ones (a ramification that usually results in a throughput loss between 25% and 40%) is the protection mechanism.  When the the AP operates in mixed mode, it transmits data using the protection mechanism and it uses Beacon and Probe Response frames to tell WiFi devices to use the protection mechanism.  An AP or device using the protection mechanism will precede its data frame transmissions with the transmission of a non-data carrying frame called a request to send (RTS) or a clear to send (CTS).  The RTS and CTS frames are always sent at a data rate that the legacy devices can understand.  For example, a WiFi network with a mix of 802.11a and 802.11ac devices would see 802.11a (24 Mbps, typically) RTS and/or CTS frames sent in advance of data that would be sent using VHT rates (up to 1,300 Mbps with today's gear).

An important note in all of this is that if there is no mixed mode, then there doesn't need to be any protection mechanism.  If you've got a bunch of HT devices all associated to an HT AP, then there shouldn't be any RTS or CTS frames slowing down the data.

Rough & Tumble Films (a movie production company whose owners I'm friends with and who have a little country noir called "We Gotta Get Out Of This Place" airing on the Starz network later this year) has a WiFi network with an HT AP and all HT (or VHT) devices.  (See the Probe Request frame below showing the "R&T" network indicating that all devices are HT-capable.)


The R&T WiFi network should see HT data frames going across the WiFi channel without any RTS and/or CTS frames slowing it down.  That is not, however, what shows up in my WildPackets OmniPeek capture.  (See that the highlighted data frames below are sent at HT rates of 243 Mbps and 300 Mbps, but they are surrounded by RTS and CTS frames sent at 24 Mbps.)


What gives, I wondered?  Are the Probe Response frames coming from the AP giving me bad information?  Are devices acting up?  My initial capture was done on data going to and from my laptop (MacBook Air using dual-band, two-stream 802.11n), so I wanted to add my phone to the network to see if anything was different.

When I added my phone (iPhone 5 using dual-band, single-stream 802.11n), the same behavior occurred.  More 24 Mbps RTS and CTS frames were surrounding my HT (this time 135 Mbps or 150 Mbps) data.


I noticed a trend when investigating all of this protection mechanism traffic on my friends' non-mixed mode WiFi.  I noticed that the RTS frames were only being sent by my devices.  The APs were never sending an RTS frame.  Beyond that, I noticed that when the AP was the transmitter of a data frame, neither an RTS or a CTS preceded that data frame.  In short, I noticed that the AP was not using the protection mechanism, which my laptop and phone were.

I know, then, that Apple devices (both iOS and OS X) slow down the channels they are using by acting like it's mixed mode even when it's not.  What I don't know is, Why?  Did Apple make a mistake?  Is there some HT or VHT protocol that I am unaware of that causes devices to use the protection mechanism even when APs don't?  Or is Apple doing this on purpose because someone at Apple thinks that their devices function better when the protection mechanism is always on?

After seeing Apple devices voluntarily engage in the protection mechanism, it made me think back to a question that I received while doing a Reddit AMA last year.  A person asked about RTS/CTS being used to manage network traffic and getting devices to cooperate.  The person from Reddit mentioned that he (sorry ladies, but when his Reddit handle is "ShadowHawk109" and he posts about beer, WiFi and William Shatner, it's got to be a guy) did work in academia, so I just assumed that he didn't know what he was talking about.  Maybe he was on to something.  Maybe Apple believes that their devices will have a more consistent data connection over WiFi if RTS/CTS frames are being used all the time, and so they've enabled it in their devices.  Maybe Apple doesn't care that much if their devices cause the maximum available throughput to be lower on the channel.

Whatever the reason may be that Apple devices have been programmed to use RTS/CTS frames, WiFi professionals are going to have to deal with the impact.  It could mean that our throughput tests mean even less and that our ability to support high density deployments has been expanded.

***

If you like my blog, you can support it by shopping through my Amazon link or donating Bitcoin to 1N8m1o9phSkFXpa9VUrMVHx4LJWfratseU

Comments

  1. Ben,

    Not necessarily that RTS/CTS always slows down the overall performance.
    RTS/CTS are good for reliability; especially in 11ac environment.
    Infact, with 11ac, RTS-CTS protection along with AMPDU over AMSDU performs better than without RTS for all the tests that I have been doing.

    Its not bad at all to do RTS-CTS anymore;
    The penalty are actually very less for the extra reliability.

    ReplyDelete
  2. RTS/CTS diminishes throughput capacity. As stated in the article, if the counterweight is an improvement in consistency, then that's good.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Interesting article Ben! I have been investigating lots of RTS/CTS on my WLAN for some time and was actually hoping to garner your opinion, but couldn't find a contact-me e-mail address. I think it might be the same thing, but I'm not familiar enough with packet traces to be sure. (yet!).

    ReplyDelete
  4. Some information about phone locators you could find here

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you a lot for providing individuals with a very spectacular possibility to read critical reviews from this site.


    Data Science Training in Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  6. Online casino BGAOC big winnings and lots of lucky games are waiting for you. all slot machine games successful do not wait, make your luck smile to you.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Гибкая світлодіодна лента лучшая на рынке, я обычно покупа в Экодио, лучше не найти.

    ReplyDelete
  8. All good. I am a newcomer, so I jerked until the money was withdrawn. I waited 2 days on Yandex. Thanks to the admins and support service for listening to my whining on the forum and in the chat. Play people! Do not be greedy. All the rules with this casino perfect online casino games I often spend my time here

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great post about iPhone wifi issues. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.

    ExcelR Data Science

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great post i must say and thanks for the information. Education is definitely a sticky subject. However, is still among the leading topics of our time. I appreciate your post and look forward to more.
    date analytics certification training courses
    data science courses training
    data analytics certification courses in Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  11. With so many books and articles coming up to give gateway to make-money-online field and confusing reader even more on the actual way of earning money,




    BIG DATA COURSE MALAYSIA

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks for the informative and helpful post, obviously in your blog everything is good..
    Data Science Course in Pune

    ReplyDelete
  13. This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, These type of articles keeps the users interest in the website, and keep on sharing more ... good luck.Data Science Courses

    ReplyDelete
  14. DJ Hire in London, DJ agencies London
    Dj Required has been setup by a mixed group of London’s finest Dj’s, a top photographer and cameraman. Together we take on Dj’s, Photographers and Cameramen with skills and the ability required to entertain and provide the best quality service and end product. We supply Bars, Clubs and Pubs with Dj’s, Photographers, and Cameramen. We also supply for private hire and other Occasions. Our Dj’s, Photographers and Cameramen of your choice, we have handpicked the people we work with

    ReplyDelete
  15. You will get an introduction to the Python programming language and understand the importance of it. How to download and work with Python along with all the basics of Anaconda will be taught. You will also get a clear idea of downloading the various Python libraries and how to use them.
    Topics
    About Excelr Solutions and Innodatatics
    Introduction to Python
    Installation of Anaconda Python
    Difference between Python2 and Python3
    Python Environment
    Operators
    Identifiers
    Exception Handling (Error Handling)

    [url=https://www.excelr.com/data-science-certification-course-training-in-singapore]Excelr Solutions[/url]

    ReplyDelete
  16. Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article.
    I just got to this amazing site not long ago. I was actually captured with the piece of resources you have got here. Big thumbs up for making such wonderful blog page!.
    technewworld.in.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Going to graduate school was a positive decision for me. I enjoyed the coursework, the presentations, the fellow students, and the professors. And since my company reimbursed 100% of the tuition, the only cost that I had to pay on my own was for books and supplies. Otherwise, I received a free master’s degree. All that I had to invest was my time.


    machine learning certification

    ReplyDelete
  18. Very interesting,good job and thanks for sharing such a good blog.your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it.You’re doing a great job.Keep it up.
    How to write best comment that approve fast

    ReplyDelete
  19. FLOETEA IS AN INNOVATIVE Iced_tea PRODUCT MADE FROM NATURAL TEA LEAVES
    IT IS A Healthy_iced_tea , LOW CALORIE, LOW CARB soft_drink WITH NATURAL LEMON FLAVOR
    FLOETEA ZERO IS A DELICIOUS, HEALTHY sugar_free_drink ICED TEA DRINK MADE FROM NATURAL TEA Leaves.
    .And this is a Healthy_soft_drink .

    try this healthy_drink to keep your body healthy

    try this yummy Iced_tea you will love it.

    this tea is Healthy_iced_tea complete tasty,

    this tea is fullysugar_free_drink and awesome.

    try this new soft_drink and feel the taste.

    this tea is Healthy_soft_drink which is very healthy.

    visit this site and know more about floetea.

    ReplyDelete
  20. PhenQ_Reviews 2019 – WHAT IS PhenQ ?


    How_to_use_PhenQ ?This is a powerful slimming formula made by combining the multiple weight loss
    benefits of variousPhenQ_ingredients. All these are conveniently contained in
    one pill. It helps you get the kind of body that you need. The ingredients of
    the pill are from natural sources so you don’t have to worry much about the side
    effects that come with other types of dieting pills.Is_PhenQ_safe ? yes this is completly safe.
    Where_to_buy_PhenQ ? you can order online.PhenQ Scam ? this medicine is not scam at all.


    Watch this PhenQ_Reviews to know more.
    Know about PhenQ Scam from here.
    know Is_PhenQ_safe for health.
    you don`t know How_to_use_PhenQ check this site

    wanna buy phenq check this site and know Where_to_buy_PhenQ and how to use.

    check the PhenQ_ingredients to know more.

    what is PhenQ check this site.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thanks for sharing such a nice Blog.I like it.
    AVG support number

    ReplyDelete
  22. free SHIPPING
    its fashion mania item site with free SHIPPING all over the world.
    women clothing,cosmetics bags sun glasses & health n beauty

    ReplyDelete
  23. Car Maintenance Tips That You Must Follow


    For everyone who owns it, Car Maintenance Tips need to know.
    Where the vehicle is currently needed by everyone in the world to
    facilitate work or to be stylish.
    You certainly want the vehicle you have always been in maximum
    performance. It would be very annoying if your vehicle isn’t even
    comfortable when driving.
    Therefore to avoid this you need to know Vehicle Maintenance Tips or Car Tips
    Buy New Car visit this site to know more.

    wanna Buy New Car visit this site.
    you dont know about Car Maintenance see in this site.
    wanna know about Car Tips click here.
    know more about Hot car news in here.

    ReplyDelete
  24. The Math behind the data analytics is resolved.
    Data Science Course is the mining of the data for analysing it through qualitative and quantitative methods to interpret meaningful insights.
    These insights will be helpful while taking critical decisions to improve the efficiency of the business output.
    Data analyst is a professional who performs these activities to reveal the hidden truths from the selected data.
    As per the Harvard study, data analytics will be a highly demanded profession for the next few years in all parts of the world




    Data Science Course

    ReplyDelete
  25. Sehar News is a wide area that envelops pakistan news , kashmir news , International News, Sports News, Arts and
    Entertainment News, Science and Technology, Business News, latest news in urdu , Education News and today news Columns.
    The perusers can snatch most recent urdu news dependent on different political and get-together
    occurring in the nation. Sehar News covers the most recent and up and coming news features, Read today urdu news and top stories from different backgrounds and carries it to the viewers



    wanna know latest pakistan news ? click pakistan news and know more.

    Read latest news in urdu and know more .

    read all the latest urdu news in this site.

    you dont know ? about today news click here and know more.

    know the current news of kashmir news check here.

    read all about today urdu news and gain knowledge.

    ReplyDelete
  26. LogoSkill, Custom Logo Design Services
    is specifically a place where plain ideas converted into astonishing and amazing designs. You buy a logo design, we feel proud in envisioning
    our client’s vision to represent their business in the logo design, and this makes us unique among all. Based in USA we are the best logo design, website design and stationary
    design company along with the flayer for digital marketing expertise in social media, PPC, design consultancy for SMEs, Start-ups, and for individuals like youtubers, bloggers
    and influencers. We are the logo design company, developers, marketers and business consultants having enrich years of experience in their fields. With our award winning
    customer support we assure that, you are in the hands of expert designers and developers who carry the soul of an artist who deliver only the best.

    Custom Logo Design Services

    ReplyDelete
  27. Great post i must say and thanks for the information. Education is definitely a sticky subject. However, is still among the leading topics of our time. I appreciate your post and look forward to more.
    rpa training in malaysia

    ReplyDelete
  28. Ez battery reconditioning reviews - You can now easily revive your old batteries with this
    Ez battery reconditioning pdf which provides step by step instructions for recondition a battery.
    Ez battery reconditioning blog publishes how Ez battery reconditioning programs works
    and where buy Ez battery reconditioning step by step program online after this
    candid Ez battery reconditioning reviews. Battery reconditioning course is newbie friendly. It may help you
    set up and run your own battery reconditioning business by learning this skill at home.
    How to recondition a battery with Ez battery reconditioning .
    Have you heard about Tom Ericson's Ez battery reconditioning reviews technique and
    are wondering whether it is possible or not. visit https://ezbatteryreconditioninginfo.com/ this site to know more. Thank you every one.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I curious more interest in some of them hope you will give more information on this topics in your next articles.
    data science course

    ReplyDelete
  30. Paysay provides reliable money transfer to Australia, cash orders, bank transfers, and money transfers. Far and away the foremost convenient thanks to transferring cash recently are to try and do a money transfer through a specialist cash transfer company. So, there we've got many of the most choices printed and here square measure many further tips for you to think about once creating a cash transfer:
    Assume ahead.
    It perhaps that you just will save cash by performing arts delayed dealing that is performed over many days, like the kind of transfer Xoom provide elaborate higher than.
    Look around.
    Money transfer app

    ReplyDelete
  31. Excelr’s online training in Guidewire is customized and for good enough reasons. Consider what regular trainers offer. A typica Digital Marketing Course in Sydney
    would take learners through the basics
    of Guidewire, teach them about configuration and understanding of various models, go on to organizing the claims centre and then best practices. This type of generalized
    training is of little use to employees handling specific parts like claims management, policy management or billing. Excelr’s custom online training addresses gaps and goes
    in-depth into specifics for each employee and his role. The result is that employees emerge better empowered and knowledgeable as well as skilled in what they have to deal with
    on a day to day basis.Unlike others, Excelr does not believe in a one size fits all approach in corporate training if highest efficiency and productivity are the goals.
    Each employee’s role is analyzed and a custom package is tailored to bring him up to speed. This has two benefits. One, the learner is motivated to learn because what he
    learns directly concerns his areas of work. Two, he learns more, in-depth and at speed. The training is online so he can access materials any time he is free and proceed at
    his convenience. He can access a tutor anytime he faces any issue while learning and become perfect in the selected modules. Tutors also go beyond to transfer the knowledge
    they have gained through years of hands-on experience and give insights that are not usually available in a regular course. By establishing a one-to-one relationship with the
    tutor, the learner remains committed and gets to know far more than he would be he to attend a classroom-based course.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Every business these days need to collect data at every point of the manufacturing and sales process to understand the journey of the product.
    This may include applications, clicks, interactions, and so many other details related to the business process which can help define goals in a better way.
    Therefore, we bring you the list of benefits which you can reap with the use of Digital Marketing Course in Sydney in your process of management.
    every business has a single reason for which the interaction of the customer and the seller is established and it is the product to be sold. Therefore, it is very crucial
    that you must add relevance to your product by understanding the needs of the customers with the addition of features and design improvements which can make your product a
    perfect fit for the target audience. This can be easily achieved with the right interpretation skills which you can only get with Data Analytics Certification.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Hi,
    Good job & thank you very much for the new information, i learned something new. Very well written. It was sooo good to read and usefull to improve knowledge. Who want to learn this information most helpful. One who wanted to learn this technology IT employees will always suggest you take big data hadoop training in pune. Because big data hadoop course in pune is one of the best that one can do while choosing the course.

    ReplyDelete




  34. Thank you so much for sharing the article. Really I get many valuable information from the article
    With our Digital Marketing Training, re-discover your creative instinct to design significant
    marketing strategies to promote a product/service related to any organization from any business sector.

    Digital Marketing Course


    ReplyDelete
  35. Tech Gadgets reviews and latest Tech and Gadgets news updates, trends, explore the facts, research, and analysis covering the digital world.
    You will see Some Tech reviews below,

    lg bluetooth headset : You will also wish to keep design and assorted features in mind. The most essential part of the design here is the buttonsof lg bluetooth headset .

    Fastest Car in the World : is a lot more than the usual number. Nevertheless, non-enthusiasts and fans alike can’t resist the impulse to brag or estimate according to specifications. Fastest Car in the World click here to know more.

    samsung galaxy gear : Samsung will undoubtedly put a great deal of time and even more cash into courting developers It is looking for partners and will allow developers to try out
    different sensors and software. It is preparing two variants as they launched last year. samsung galaxy gear is very use full click to know more.

    samsung fridge : Samsung plans to supply family-oriented applications like health care programs and digital picture frames along with games It should stick with what they know and they
    do not know how to produce a quality refrigerator that is worth what we paid. samsung fridge is very usefull and nice product. clickcamera best for travel: Nikon D850: Camera It may be costly, but if you’re trying to find the very best camera you can purchase at this time, then Nikon’s gorgeous DX50 DSLR will
    probably mark each box. The packaging is in a vibrant 45.4-megapixel full-frame detector, the picture quality is simply wonderful. However, this is just half the story. Because of a complex 153-point AF system along with a brst rate of 9 frames per minute. camera best specification. click here to know more.

    visit https://techgadgets.expert/ this site to know more.

    ReplyDelete
  36. I like you article. if you you want to saw Sufiyana Pyaar Mera Star Bharat Serials Full
    Sufiyana Pyaar Mera

    ReplyDelete

  37. Thank you so much for sharing the article.
    Women fashion has always been in vouge. It has been continually changing, evolving, rebrading itself with every passing day. Compared to men,

    women's clothing has far more variety in terms of colors options, fabrics and styles.

    Just take a step out of your home and you would spot either a grocery store or a women's clothing shop first! No wonder even in the online world women are spoilt for choices
    with the likes of Amazon, Flipkart bringing the neighbourhood retail stores to you on your fingertips.
    Here we try to explore what are the other shopping options you have for women and what they are known for.


    Glambees is relatively a new entrant in the market but you will definitely love the collection you will find here. You mostly find beautiful ethic wear collections in sarees
    and salwar suits but some really good tops to pair with your jeans too.women's online clothing store dealing in sarees, salwar suits, dress materials, kurtis, lehengas,
    casual wear, wedding wear, party wear and more. The selection and affordability is its USP.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Kaamil Traning is fastly growing Training Center in Qatar
    that aims to provide Value through Career Linked training, Professional Development Programs, Producing Top Notch
    Professionals, Provide Bright Career Path. Kaamil Training Leveraging best-in-class global alliances and strategic partnerships with Alluring Class rooms, Great Learning
    Environment. The toppers study with us and market leaders will be your instructors.
    At Kaamil Training our focus is to make sure you have all the knowledge and exam technique you need to achieve your
    ACCA Course in Qatar qualification. Our core objective is to help you
    pass your exams and our ability to do this is demonstrated by our exceptional pass rates.

    ReplyDelete
  39. It is so easy now to catch your spouse cheating click here to download the app.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Go To Sleep, Go To Sleep, Go To Sleep Little iPhone

Roam, If You Want to (As Long as Your Channels Are 20 Mhz Wide)

WPA3 Adds Four Security Enhancements, One of Which Matters