Crack the 40 (MHz Wide Channel) Open, Homie and Guzzle (the Bandwidth Available Over) It

Everybody likes high Wi-Fi speeds.  Because high Wi-Fi speeds mean that the channel is being used more efficiently (often false).  An efficient channel means that there's more available throughput (only in sterile test environments) and more available throughput means that more users can be supported concurrently (completely wrong).

Unfortuantely, high Wi-Fi speeds sometimes (all the timecome at a cost.  To get higher Wi-Fi speeds, wider channels must be used (which makes the Wi-Fi suck).  Using wider channels means that fewer channels will be available (plus it ups minimum RSSI requirements, which just about guarantees a bad design).  It is therefore essential that wireless professionals analyze the environment and carefully choose whether to use 40 MHz or 80 MHz wide channels (or they could stop wasting everyone's time and just stick to 20 MHz channels).

But this blog post isn't about choosing the correct channel bandwidth (although it should be, because tons of Wi-Fi goes bad because wide channels are configured).  This blog is to explain how Wi-Fi devices use 40 MHz and 80 MHz channels, and how spectrum analyzers sometimes make channel bonding look worse than it actually is (which it kills me to say, because using 40 MHz or 80 MHz channels is almost always bad).

I post this blog begrudgingly.  I would prefer to just say, "fuggetaboutit, use 20 MHz channels" and leave it at that.  I would prefer to just write a bunch of stuff about how the 802.11 Working Group should've made 802.11ac a standard for residential Wi-Fi and how a separate 802.11 amendment should've been created for enterprise Wi-Fi.  And I would prefer to go on a big ol' rant about how frustrating it is that 40 MHz/80 MHz channels deliver higher throughput numbers, but that channel bonding makes Wi-Fi failures (disconnected users, lack of Internet access, etc.) far more likely.  So, it really, really pains me to have to write this blog post where I defend 40 MHz/80 MHz channels against some of the negative comments I've seen written about them.

Here's the thing: I want this blog to be about LEARNING.  I believe that if the people who work in Wi-Fi really understand Wi-Fi, then more better Wi-Fi will happen.  And so I feel compelled to explain why spectrum analyzers give a deceptive picture of how efficiently 40 MHz and 80 MHz channels are used.

Here's a look at my 40 MHz channel during a large file download:


My wireless router is set to channel 48/-1, meaning that I am using a 40 MHz wide channel covering channels 44 and 48, with channel 48 being the primary 20 MHz channel.

If you look closely, you can see that channel 48 is slightly more dense than channel 44.  If I would have been in an environment with a large number of devices, the difference would have been more pronounced.  The 20 MHz spectrum for channel 48 would have showed much more activity than the 20 MHz channel for channel 44.

When Spectrum Analysis Goes Wrong

Wi-Fi folks sometimes make the mistake of believing that using 40 MHz channels (or 80 MHz channels, for that matter) causes frequency to be "underused".  The theory is that since the density/duty cycle is higher for the primary 20 MHz channel, that means that the non-primary 20 MHz channel(s) is(are) being wasted to some degree.  

People who get channel usage wrong always seem to have the same reasoning behind it.  They think that some of their users have devices that only support 20 MHz channels.  The idea is that when those  20 MHz-only devices are active, the unused 20 MHz (or 60 MHz, in the case of 80 MHz channels) goes to waste.

In reality, modern Wi-Fi devices support 5 GHz channel widths wider than 20 MHz.  The last year that that saw 20 MHz-only support for 5 GHz devices was 2011.  That's a long time ago and chances are 99%+ that lack of 40 MHz/80 MHz channel support is not the reason why spectrum density & duty cycle look lopsided.

The Protocol Analyzer Shows Why

The real reason that 40 MHz/80 MHz channel usage looks lopsided is because of control and management traffic.  Modern Wi-Fi devices send & receive all management frames and control frames using a 20 MHz channel (this is probably because 20 MHz channels are more reliable than 40 MHz/80 MHz channels, WHICH IS WHY IT PAINS ME TO DEFEND THEM IN THIS BLOG).  

An OmniPeek capture of my primary 20 MHz channel shows it clearly:


Less than 1% of the 20 MHz traffic on my primary channel is data traffic.  

At the same time, my full 40 MHz channel shows plenty of data:


For my test I only had one device active on channel 48.  In the real world, with dozens of devices on channel 48, the result will be the same: tons of non-data traffic over the primary 20 MHz channel, but almost no data traffic.

The reason why a spectrum analyzer gives deceptive information about Wi-Fi is that a spectrum analyzer is just showing raw channel activity.  A spectrum analyzer has no ability to differentiate between data and non-data traffic.  When data frames occupy the channel, the spectrum analyzer sees the entire 40 MHz/80 MHz used.  When management or control frames occupy the channel, only the primary 20 MHz channel gets used.  Hence, the lopsided density/duty cycle readings when analyzing a 40 MHz/80 MHz channel for raw spectrum activity.

Using a spectrum analyzer to view 20 MHz wide channels is also going to show deceptive information.  The total channel space will show density/duty cycle numbers that make it seem like channel space is being used more efficiently, but that's not the case.  The "more efficient" channel usage would just be due to the additional management and control traffic that comes when two APs use 20 MHz channels in place of a single AP using a 40 MHz channel.  The amount of channel time available for data (which is what really matters) would remain the same.

All That Having Been Said

40 MHz/80 MHz 802.11n/802.11ac Wi-Fi channels are just as efficient as 20 MHz channels (maybe even more efficient), but narrower channels are still best for most enterprises.  20 MHz channels allow for fewer devices per channel and for data to be successful at lower signal-to-noise ratios (SNR).  Those things matter a lot.  They matter a lot more than hitting a high number on a throughput test.  So, if good Wi-Fi is the goal, ignore this blog's defense of 40 MHz/80 MHz channels and stick to 20 MHz.

***
If you like my blog, you can support it by shopping through my Amazon link.  You can also donate Bitcoin to 1N8m1o9phSkFXpa9VUrMVHx4LJWfratseU or to my QR code:













Twitter: @Ben_SniffWiFi
ben at sniffwifi dot com

Comments

  1. Please check teh website and its link as the website is not opening. I checked my internet connetion, it is some issue at your end, please resolve as I want to read the post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I read this article. I think You put a lot of effort to create this article. I appreciate your work.
    thesis Writing Service

    ReplyDelete


  3. Our client can choose any of them as per their convenient. We are also open to send our angels any other place of your choice. Call Girls in Connaught Place are waiting eagerly to meet you. You need to decide whether you want to meet them at home or at any hotel. If you are facing any challenges in arranging any place, let me inform you that we have tie-ups with 3 start hotels as well as 5 start hotels. Check our other services...
    Escorts in Vasant Kunj
    Escorts in Connaught Place
    Escorts Service in Vasant Kunj
    Escorts in Vasant Kunj
    Escorts Service in Vasant Kunj

    ReplyDelete
  4. Looking for Labrador retriever puppies online store puppies available to be purchased If a Lab little dog isn't given appropriate consideration and preparing they could create conduct issues later on. Ensure you're set up to care for a Labrador pup and address the entirety of their issues. Cautiously consider why you need to Golden Labrador puppy online a Labrador little dog prior to surrendering your money and if a Labrador is the correct canine for your family and way of life Buy labrador retriever near me. In case you're certain a Labrador doggy is for you ensure you're buying a sound pet. Investigate the Little dog contract or click our link for direction.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Buy magnetic eyelashes online Designed for you BE M~NETIC BE LASHFUL GLAM look without the mess.Fast, flawless lashes that give you the perfect lift in just one click.So WHY M~NECTIC? It's the magnetic lash without the Flash. Our lashes are cleverly designed with you in mind! Our high quality design provides you with magnetic Where to buy magnetic eyelashes lashes that click together creating a flawless look for every occasion.The BEST part? Our effortless lashes are the best quality and leader in the industry today.
    Buy now and receive 50% off all orders ...Buy magnetic eyeliner online ,Where to buy magnetic eyeliner , Magnetic eyelashes online store , Magnetic eyelashes and eyeliner set , Magnetic eyeliner online store , Buy magnetic eyeliner and lashes , Best place to buy magnetic eyelashes , Best magnetic eyelashes online , Best place to buy magnetic eyeliner and many others products.
    http://sprinters1llc.com/

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you for sharing this useful information and keep writing this type post. we offers Hard Disk Drive USB Converter online at affordable price. You need to set up an outer hard drive fenced in area prior to changing interior hard drive to USB, it functions as the Hard Disk Drive USB converter to permit you to move an inner Hard Disk Drive toward an outside USB drive. Buy 8 Port USB Super Fast Charger online from bestbydezign.com at cheapest price. This gadget offers quick charging and this element won't cause your telephone to overheat. It additionally incorporates two USB port yields. Additionally, charging 2 gadgets on the double won't diminish the charging ability of each USB port yield.

    The Conveniently Simple Portable Bluetooth Speakers that is ideal for making and getting little telephone calls advantageously. With strong form quality, simple arrangement and top-class sound execution that gives a false representation of its little size, it is an extraordinary decision in case you are searching for an individual gathering speakerphone.

    The Pull up Lazy Tablet Bracket is ideal for individuals who need to see their telephones or tablets in a without hands climate. The base of the section is looking like an external eight, which is immovably upheld to forestall shaking. The section is furnished with a non-slip silicone cushion to secure your tablet and cell phone.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ourtime login is the leading dating site for mature men and women. Our aim to help that kind of seniors who looking for right partner for date. We can help you how to create account on Ourtime and how Login ourtime to a search partner.

    Just like ourtime, Zoosk login is another dating site for seniors. It is most popular website for dating in USA. So if you have any issue in Zoosk sign in, Zoosk membership or any other kind of query then visit our website for more information.

    ReplyDelete
  8. SarahBits Inc is best Ecommerce development company in Ohio. If you are a website/business owner and looking for best Ecommerce designing company then we are one stop destination for you. We have professional and skilled teams for such services.

    Our team also working for Portal development and designing for any kind of business/service. We are well known Responsive website development Company in Ohio, USA. For more detail about our services, visit our website or call our executives.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Before hiring a home/office cleaners you should make sure that company is licensed or not. Our company Nemoclean is licensed and has skilled technicians in our team for deep cleaning services. You can hire our company for home cleaners in Columbus in USA.

    We offer all kind of cleaning services like office, house apartment and more. We are well known commercial cleaners in Columbus USA. Contact us for any cleaning services.

    small office cleaning

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thank you for sharing this useful information and keep writing this type post. We have been taking our Mobile car washing Phoenix near you. Keep your vehicle totally cleaned at each level. Whether or not it is applying wax to the paint or cleaning inside, every movement of the cycles requires putting aside the additional push to fastidiousness.

    Mobile car washing Arizona business might be a savvy on account of make huge loads of money. In any case, you might want to take a position sensible cash at first. The components of the vehicle wash business is enormous. The interest for money wash close by vehicle itemizing administrations is furthermore developing very fast.

    Mobile car detailing Arizona should be close by, simple to book, and easy for you to appreciate. Our versatile auto specifying administrations are worked around making it basic for the regular individual to get top quality auto enumerating in their own garage.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Go To Sleep, Go To Sleep, Go To Sleep Little iPhone

Why Are You Slowing Down My WiFi, Apple? To Make Things Better?

Five Facts About 6 GHz Wi-Fi